This section is from "The Horticulturist, And Journal Of Rural Art And Rural Taste", by P. Barry, A. J. Downing, J. Jay Smith, Peter B. Mead, F. W. Woodward, Henry T. Williams. Also available from Amazon: Horticulturist and Journal of Rural Art and Rural Taste.
A certain youth who signally failed in establishing the "Florist" in Philadelphia, has taken upon himself to give an opinion upon what a periodical should be, thus trying to shame his own, while he gives vent to his spleen. No doubt he con-siders himself qualified to give an opinion on the bench of the Supreme Court, or on any subject; but I suspect his place will always be where he began, at the lower end of the potting-bench. " Scott's Seedling Strawberry," noticed in the " Country Gentleman," was no doubt named after him, as both he and it are " wholly without flavor." I find the following merited rebuke to this upstart in the "Country Gentleman." Mr. S. had essayed a reply to your correspondent, Mr. Allen, who says:
" Another word: a writer, R. R. S., immediately following your editorial, under the head of 'Pear fungus' says,' a prominent critic has lately asserted that of the causes of the crack and blight which attacks the Virgalieu and other pears, " nothing is known but that it exists;"' and goes on to quote what' one of the ablest Cryptogamic botanists of the day' says about it This new and wonderful authority talks of ' Cladosporium,' and ' Helminthosporium!' Shades of Lindley, Michaux, Nattall, and company, deliver us from such a commentator as R. R. S., and let him tell us in understandable English language what the cause of the * crack and blight,' is if be knows it, and then how to avoid and cure them, without smothering us in nonsense".
 
Continue to: