This section is from "The Horticulturist, And Journal Of Rural Art And Rural Taste", by P. Barry, A. J. Downing, J. Jay Smith, Peter B. Mead, F. W. Woodward, Henry T. Williams. Also available from Amazon: Horticulturist and Journal of Rural Art and Rural Taste.
EDITOR Horticulturist: In the last two years I have collected and planted at "Woodburn Farm" (near Columbus, Ohio), some fifty of the newer varieties of strawberries, chiefly for the purpose of testing their value as to growth, hardiness and prolificacy in the soil and climate of that region. Some of them are well known in many sections, others are new American seedlings, and a few are recent importations from abroad by the Agricultural Department, whence I obtained them. They were all planted two feet apart, in rows four feet asunder, so as to permit of horse cultivation, and they have been kept reasonably clean and runners cut by running a small plow occasionally between the rows. The soil is clay-loam, surface-drained. Last December the rows were all covered with straw, as a winter protection, but I have not been able to perceive any special benefit from this much vaunted but somewhat troublesome operation. Some of the varieties were found to be entirely frozen out, while others were but slightly injured. Again, in the case of some varieties where the straw had been blown off in places, the exposed plants seemed to be in about as good condition as those which remained covered.
On the whole, I am inclined to doubt the correctness of the popular theory of strawberry "mulching," or covering, and have found it, in the growing season, especially, a decided nuisance, for weeds and grass will grow up through it inevitably, and cannot be destroyed until the straw is entirely removed from both rows and spaces.
Very respectfully, F. A. Simpkins.
Agriculturist, moderately thrifty, no runners.
Abraham Lincoln, totally destroyed.
Ballard's Seedling, robust growth, shy bearer.
Boyden's 30, splendid grower, fair bearer.
British Queen, fine foliage, has not borne.
Burr's Pine, fair grower, superior flavor.
Belle Bordelais, thrifty, except where trampled.
Caliope, good growth, poor bearer.
Champion, died out, complete failure.
Chas. Downing, moderate, healthy grower.
Colfax, immense foliage, small fruit.
Coppick, hardy, new, promises well.
Department Seedlings, 1 to 9, No. 3 best grower.
Durand's Seedling, splendid grower, very hardy.
Globe, much injured by cold.
Glocde's Fine, good growth, poor bearer.
Golden Seeded, moderately thrifty.
Green Prolific, first-rate growth, not prolific.
Gen. Sherman, inferior, not desirable.
Halleck's Prolific, thrifty, poor and small.
Haquin, new, badly winter-killed.
Higley's Everbearing, thrifty, ripens regularly.
Hovey's Seedling, fair grower, fine flavor.
Jucunda, vigorous, fruit not large.
Lady Of The Lake, strong grower, moderate bearer.
Laurella, strong grower, barren thus far.
Leeds' Prolific, moderately vigorous, fruit small.
Lennig's White, strong growth, superior flavor.
Matilda, new, promises well as to growth.
Naomi, vivid green, very vigorous.
Napoleon III, winter-killed, utterly destroyed.
Negro, strong grower, much like Wilson.
Nicanor, partially winter-killed.
Paxton, hardy, fine handsome growth.
Peake'X Emperor, magnificently green.
Philadelphia, moderate grower, sure bearer.
Prince Of Wales, badly injured by cold.
Reed's Pine, good, hardy grower, very late.
Romeyn's Seedling, fair grower, leaves brown-specked.
Triomphe De Gand, moderately vigorous, healthy.
Trollop's Victoria, fair growth, brownish foliage.
Washington (Iowa), persistent grower and runner.
Wilder, new, vigorous and healthy growth.
Wilson, of course, great grower and bearer.
Rich deep red, shaded with crimson; flowers in large clusters.
An elegant variety for beds and masses, shaded crimson, of very dwarf habit.
[We agree with Mr. Barker, that the improved varieties of the Gladiolus are among the most beautiful objects which adorn the flower-garden. The new ones introduced last spring are strikingly beautiful, and we trust will have a wide dissemination. - Ed].
Very large, about equal to Trollope's Victoria, which it resembles in color, general appearance, flavor, and productiveness, but not in form, being generally compressed at the sides, or of a cock's-comb form.
I)r. Swazey, of Louisiana, says that as a market fruit, it lacks color, as a desert fruit quality, but accords to it great value for hardiness, productiveness, and large size. In a specimen orchard of a hundred varieties of pears on quince, set out in 1854, there were but two trees that outgrew the Triomphe de Jodoigne, and not a dozen that excelled it in productiveness - most of them were handsomer and nearly all of them better. This was in our garden. Out in the big orchard, where we had over five hundred varieties of the pear in bearing, the Triomphe de Jodoigne did not equal, either in beauty or quality, one-fifth of them. Few excelled it in soundness, productiveness, vigor or luxuriance of growth. Our experience has been on a strong clay loam; a light sandy soil may produce a different result.
 
Continue to: